It was never a labour shortage
You wrote a script. You installed something to check it was followed. Both worked exactly as intended.

The industry’s narrative on staffing is settled.
The people aren’t out there. The ones who are don’t want the work. The ones working never seem to stay long. They just don’t have what it takes. Not like we used to. It’s a shortage, and you wait it out or you pay more.
That read has one thing badly wrong.
It treats the shortage as weather, something happening to your venue from outside it. Something you can’t influence. Can’t control.
It isn’t.
For a lot of venues, the shortage is an issue. It’s the thing the operating system produces when it’s running correctly. And it’s been running for decades.
Here’s what’s hard to swallow. Nothing in what follows requires anyone to have made a bad decision. Every decision was made for a good reason, installed by a competent operator, and did the job it was bought to do.
Just like the Industry bodies, the influencers and the consultants told us all to.
But it’s not authentic. It is not hospitality. It’s manufactured sincerity. It’s performative warmth. And it comes at a cost.
That cost has a name, and it is older than any of this.
Arlie Hochschild called it emotional labour, back in 1983. A display produced to the organisation’s rules about feeling, and sold along with the shift.
Her point wasn’t that the display is fake. It’s that producing it is work. And that you are buying it whether or not anyone has priced it.
Two instruments, two parties
There are only two instruments in this. You wrote a script, a playbook, a standard, and you installed a way to check the script was followed.
The eye-contact. The greeting. The table-check at 3 minutes, or first bite. What gets said when a dish goes wrong. The upsell prompt. A reply to a google review, or a comment on an instagram reel.
It might be digital, laminated or it might just be what gets corrected in a pre-shift. or whatever you taught them when they were new. But it exists, and you wrote it to “standardise”, to remove variation.
And you’ve got to check on them too, right? Interaction timers. Mystery shopper scores. Review alerts on your phone. Social media monitoring.
Not one of these got thought of as surveillance. Each one had a stated operational reason, and each one was reasonable on its own.
Two instruments.
They land on two people: the person delivering the service, and the person receiving it. That’s 4 things happening at once, and the industry only counts one of them.
The script, and the person holding it
A script removes variation. That’s the whole point, and it does what it is designed to do.
But it also removes a decision. Every line you specify is a line somebody no longer chooses. That trade works when the specified thing is the right thing, when conversation or situation falls within the narrow definition captured by the script.
The problem is the exception.
A table that needs the pace slowed down. The pace sped up. An unrealistic expectation. A refusal to dine within the norms that management have defined. The script has nothing for these, because a script is a list of the predictable and the exception isn’t on it.
And as every person ever employed in service knows; customers can be influenced, but can never be managed.
The problem is the destruction of employee initiative and the emotional cost it demands.
Ask a different question
So ask a different question about your venue. Not what your people are told to do. Not what your people are told to say. What are they permitted to decide on their own, without asking?
Most venues can’t answer. Nobody wrote that document. It isn’t an oversight either. Once a script and a check on it are both in place, that document becomes unwritable. Anything a person may decide alone sits outside both, by definition.
That absence is the mechanism.
Harry Braverman described the same split in factory work. He called it separating conception from execution. The thinking moves off the floor, and the doing stays on it.
In manufacturing, separating who decides from who does is coherent, because the decision and the product are different things.
In service they’re the same thing.
The judgement is the product. Remove it and you haven’t tightened the operation. You’ve stopped selling what you were selling.
In hospitality we’ve evolved to both distrust our frontline staff, and fret more about the path than the destination. They can deliver an experience their guests line up to be a part of, and be cautioned for not following the script.
The script, and the person it’s aimed at
The second thing happens across the table, and it doesn’t need anyone to complain.
Guests read standardised warmth as standardised. Absent the warmth. They’ve been served by enough systems to know one when they’re inside one. The table-check reads as a table-check. It doesn’t read as someone noticing. It doesn’t read as someone caring. It’s a box being ticked.
This is the awkward part of a script working. The more reliably it’s delivered, the more clearly it reads as delivery.
This commodified, superficial veneer of friendliness fundamentally alters the host-guest relationship, because it ceases to be an authentic social exchange and is reduced to a cold, clinical, and mechanical transaction.
You paid full price for the display. The person across the table sees the actor, but isn’t lost in the movie. They’re not being cynical. They can tell the difference between judgement and compliance.
There’s maybe no complaint, because nothing went wrong. The food was “fine” and the service was technically “correct”.
But the hospitality became inhospitable.
The metric, and the person it measures
Now add the metrics.
A metric doesn’t just record behaviour. It changes who the behaviour is for. Before the micro-management, before the surveillance, the interaction was for the guest. After it, part of the interaction is for the measurement, and everyone doing the job knows exactly which part.
George Ritzer put calculability among the 4 things a rationalised system optimises for, alongside efficiency, predictability and control.
The trouble with calculability in a dining room is that it only reaches the countable part.
Warmth isn’t countable. Table-check timing is. So the timing becomes the record of the thing you actually wanted.
Watch what this does to your best people specifically.
The ones already exercising judgement now have to demonstrate compliance as well, and the two pull against each other. Slowing down for the table that needs it costs them on the timer. The recovery that actually works isn’t the scripted one. They’re now doing two jobs, and only one of them counts.
They don’t argue about it. They can’t, because nothing about it is unreasonable on paper. They just find the job has a cost that wasn’t on the tin. A personal cost.
When they go, the notice gives a tidy reason. A commute. Study. A better offer. Almost nobody writes down the real one. It sounds like a complaint about something that isn’t technically wrong.
So the resignation arrives with the wrong explanation attached, and you file it under a shortage.
The metric, and the person it recruits
The last one is the one almost nobody counts, and it’s the strangest.
Review scores put the guest inside your measurement system. Someone who came in for dinner is now, structurally, part of how your floor gets assessed. They didn’t apply for that job.
It changes the interaction on both sides. Your staff are performing for an audience that can publish. Your guests are being asked, gently and constantly, to file a report. Neither of those is hospitality. Both of them are admin, handed to people who came in to eat and people who came in to work.
Foucault made this point about a prison design with a tower in the middle.
The inmates couldn’t tell whether anyone was in the tower, so they behaved as though someone always was. The watching does its work without anyone having to watch.
Your floor runs on that principle now. You didn’t install it on purpose. You bought a review alert.
What it costs
Line the four up and the shape is obvious.
The person holding the script loses the ability to use judgement. The person it’s aimed at notices it’s gone. The person it measures performs for the measurement instead of the person. The person it recruits gets handed a job with a cost they are unwilling to pay.
One removal, 4 consequences, and only one of them is a number you can see. The resignation shows up in your turnover. The rest of it doesn’t show up anywhere at all.
That’s why the narrative persists.
You’re reading a real signal, and it’s the only signal the system produces. Turnover is visible, so turnover is what gets explained. The explanation available is that people don’t want to work.
It’s called a shortage. It’s staffing, so it looks like a staffing problem. It isn’t. It’s a design problem wearing a staffing problem’s clothes. You can’t hire out of it, because every new person walks into the same 4 things.
You didn’t lose people to a shortage. You lost them to a system that couldn’t tell your best person from your most compliant one. Neither could anyone reading the numbers it produced.
Reversing the Labour crisis in hospitality.
The move isn’t loosening the script or removing the metric. Both have a role to play. The move is writing the document nobody wrote: what your people may decide alone, without asking. Not because autonomy is nice to have. Because judgement is the product, and right now nothing in your operation says who’s allowed to use it.
-
Focus more on the outcome than the path your staff member took to get there.
-
Constant, uninterrupted emotional performance on the “front stage” under the public gaze is one of the fastest routes to psychological exhaustion. Your team needs both morale boosting breaks and a rotation of duties that takes them off of the frontline.
-
Establish a transparent, zero-tolerance policy for customer abuse (such as verbal aggression, yelling, or personal insults). Train managers to step in immediately to shield and defend staff, and make it clear that “the customer is not always right”.
-
Formally authorise and train employees to use emotional neutrality dealing with “demanding customers” (rude, aggressive, or abusive customers), forcing a warm, empathetic performance is psychologically degrading and causes severe emotive dissonance